Conceptual photograph of separate documents, a key and a leather folio on a banking meeting table

External Asset Manager vs Private Bank in Switzerland: Who Controls the Assets?

An external asset manager and a private bank can both manage a portfolio, but they place authority in different hands. A bank mandate combines investment management with a banking relationship. An external manager usually works through a separate custodian. For a client living abroad, the better choice is the arrangement whose powers, charges and exit terms can be checked in writing.

However, the distinction becomes real when something needs to change. Perhaps you want a new manager but want to keep your securities where they are. You may like your adviser but need a second custodian. Or perhaps you discover that an apparently simple annual fee leaves several other charges outside the agreement.

Those are questions about contracts and control. A polished investment presentation rarely answers them. This analysis is for clients who live outside Switzerland, hold no Swiss residence permit and are considering a Swiss investment relationship. It assumes neither that a bank will accept the client nor that an external manager can serve every country.

Start with the statement, then find the authority

Before comparing returns, ask where the account sits, who is named as its holder and which legal entity produces the statement. Next, identify who may issue investment instructions. Finally, find the document that explains how those powers end. Each answer should point to a document, rather than a relationship manager’s reassurance.

With a bank’s discretionary mandate, the bank makes investment decisions within an agreed brief. With an external asset manager, a separate firm makes those decisions under its mandate and the authority accepted by the custodian. An advisory arrangement works differently: the client generally retains the decision to approve recommendations. The title on a business card does not settle that distinction.

Consider an illustrative entrepreneur living in Dubai with an existing European portfolio. She wants advice in English, Swiss custody and the freedom to replace the investment manager. A single bank mandate could meet those needs. An external manager could also meet them. The useful question is which contract lets her change the part she dislikes without disturbing the parts she values.

That is the organising test used below: how much must the client change when one provider stops working well? It makes the comparison less glamorous, and much more practical. The broader Swiss banking guide explains the system; this article examines the division of responsibilities within an investment relationship.

Pens, a document wallet and a lock illustrating the authority granted to an external asset manager
Authority should be checked in the actual mandate and bank documents. AI-generated conceptual photography.

The three-party relationship needs three separate checks

First, an external arrangement normally involves the client, an investment manager and a custodian bank. The manager’s agreement describes the investment service. Meanwhile, the bank’s documents govern custody, banking services and accepted instructions. A power of attorney connects the two. Read the documents together, because a restriction in one document may matter more than an attractive promise in another.

For example, a manager may offer access to several custodians. That tells you something about its business model, but it does not confirm that each bank accepts your domicile, ownership structure or holdings. Ask which custodian would actually open your account, under which legal entity, and with which restrictions. A theoretical choice of ten banks is of little use if only one will accept your case.

The bank’s custody role also needs a precise description. FINMA distinguishes securities held in custody from bank deposits: custody assets such as shares and fund units belong to clients and are segregated in bankruptcy proceedings. That is a different legal position from a cash claim on the bank. It does not remove investment losses or make access instantaneous during a disruption.

For that reason, direct access to records matters. Obtain statements and access credentials from the custodian through verified channels. Compare the custodian’s records with the manager’s reports. A report prepared by the manager may be useful, but the client should be able to check the underlying account without going through that same manager.

A written map of who can do what

Decision to verifyBank investment mandateExternal-manager arrangementEvidence to request
Who holds the account?Named bank entity and account holderNamed custodian and account holderAccount agreement and direct statement
Who decides investments?Depends on discretionary/advisory serviceDepends on management/advisory mandateSigned service agreement and investment brief
Who can move money?Bank and client authority rules applyCustodian-recognised authority controlsAccepted power of attorney and payment restrictions
Who collects each fee?Map bank, product and other chargesMap manager, custodian and product chargesFee schedule, disclosures and sample reconciliation
Can management change without custody moving?Check available service conversionCheck authority revocation and successor acceptanceWritten exit and continuity procedure
Who accepts the non-resident client?Bank under its policiesManager and custodian each assess their scopeWritten domicile/entity eligibility confirmation
Original authority checklist. Entries are questions to verify, not universal contractual rights.

A licence is a starting point for checking an external asset manager

FINMA says commercial portfolio managers generally need its licence and then face ongoing supervision by an authorised supervisory organisation. Certain domestic group companies fall under a different supervisory arrangement. The regulator’s licensing page and official lists are the appropriate starting point for checking the exact firm.

Check the legal name, address, licence category and relevant supervisory organisation. A brand name, group affiliation or reference to compliance training does not replace that search. If the name on the mandate differs from the name on the register, ask for the relationship between the entities. It may have a straightforward explanation, but the client should not have to guess.

A licence also does not answer every cross-border question. A firm may operate lawfully in Switzerland yet limit the countries from which it accepts clients or the services it offers them. Ask the manager and custodian separately to confirm that they can serve your actual residence. Include other relevant facts, such as citizenship, tax status and any company or trust involved.

This is why an introduction should never be presented as guaranteed acceptance. The custodian still makes its own decision, and the service must fit the client’s circumstances. A well-prepared file can make the facts easier to assess; it cannot replace the bank’s assessment. Claims that a particular intermediary is compulsory deserve especially careful scrutiny.

Read the power of attorney as if the relationship will end

“Limited authority” sounds reassuring. It becomes meaningful only when the limits are visible. Ask whether the manager can trade, use derivatives, initiate foreign exchange, pledge assets, arrange borrowing or debit its own fees. Ask separately whether it can instruct payments or change account details. A general statement that the manager cannot withdraw funds leaves other powers unresolved.

Swissquote’s published limited power of attorney for its Forex money-manager service illustrates the need to read scope closely. The form limits withdrawals while also addressing remuneration and delegated instructions. It is a product-specific form, not a template for all Swiss securities mandates. Its value here is as evidence that authority and fee powers require separate reading.

For your own agreement, ask the custodian to describe the restrictions it actually enforces. A sentence in the manager’s sales material is weaker than a bank-recognised limit. Keep the signed version and any later amendments. If two documents conflict, resolve the point before granting access; do not assume the narrower wording automatically prevails.

Then rehearse revocation. Find the address or secure channel for giving notice, the point at which the bank treats it as effective and the treatment of orders already in progress. Check whether stopping authority also terminates the management contract. Those may be separate steps with separate financial consequences.

Independence has to survive the product shelf

A separate ownership structure can give a manager room to choose among banks and products. It does not prove that the manager’s incentives match yours. Ask who receives each payment associated with the portfolio, including charges inside funds or certificates, distribution payments and fees to connected businesses. The same questions belong in a bank comparison.

FINMA’s June 2026 guidance on products in individual portfolio management focuses on risk patterns, suitability and conflicts. The lesson for selection is to ask how a firm evaluates what it buys, rather than treating the word “independent” as the conclusion of that work.

One useful test is a product the manager knows you may question. Ask it to explain the issuer, liquidity, valuation, total cost and reason for choosing that instrument over a simpler alternative. Ask who earns money if the product stays in the account. A clear answer can support the choice; an inability to explain it should slow the decision.

Retrocessions need their own document trail. The Swiss Banking Ombudsman’s discussion of advance waivers shows why consent and disclosure matter. Do not infer an automatic refund from a general article. The mandate, disclosure and applicable legal position need examination. EGB’s Swiss private-client fee guide covers the wider charging structure.

A hand lifting layers of paper beside a calculator, illustrating layers of investment fees
A management quote may contain several separate cost layers. AI-generated conceptual photography.

The 2026 evidence makes the label less useful

In an October 2026 speech, FINMA presented end-2025 managed-asset shares by licence category: managers of collective assets accounted for 38%, while banks and securities firms accounted for 32%. The remainder below is calculated as 30%. It includes other categories; it is not an estimate of the external-manager market. Source: FINMA, 15 October 2026.

Managed assets by licence type

EGB · Research notebookObserved data
Where managed assets sit
Share of FINMA’s stated managed-asset universe · end 2025
Collective asset managers38%
Banks & securities firms32%
Other licence categories30%
0%25%50%75%100%
Hatched bar: calculated remainder, 100 − 38 − 32. It is not the EAM market share. Primary source.
Data, definitions and calculation notes
CategoryPercent
Collective asset managers38
Banks & securities firms32
Other licence categories30

The point of the comparison is its boundary. A licence category describes the provider; the client still needs to understand the activity performed and the contract signed. For example, a banking group can manage investments as well as hold them. By contrast, a separate firm can manage investments without providing the banking account. Neither fact, by itself, settles the quality of a particular mandate.

The same speech reported seven supervisory escalation cases concerning Article 17 portfolio managers in 2023, 32 in 2024 and 60 in 2025. These are case counts, not failure rates, losses or a comparison with banks. FINMA explicitly warns against judging the whole industry from this subset. The series supplies a reason to inspect controls, not a reason to reject an entire service model.

Cases over time, with the right limits

EGB · Research notebookObserved series
Supervisory cases increased
Article 17 portfolio-manager escalation cases · 2023–2025
60cases in 2025
2025
Counts of supervisory cases, not failure rates or losses. FINMA provides no denominator for this series. Source and definitions.
Data, definitions and calculation notes
YearCases
20237
202432
202560

Put every charge on the same sheet

Two proposals are comparable only after their boundaries match. Start with the management fee, then identify custody, transactions, foreign exchange, product expenses and any separate reporting or service charges. Mark each item as included, additional, variable or unknown. An unknown amount is a question to resolve, not a zero to insert into a model.

A publicly available Vontobel EAM custody brochure, valid from October 2021, separates periodic banking fees from transaction charges. Its dated terms should not be used as a current quote. It illustrates a documentary point: an external manager’s own fee cannot be assumed to include the custodian’s bill.

Ask both bidders to price the same activity: the same portfolio value, asset mix, expected turnover, currency conversions and reporting needs. Then ask what changes if those assumptions change. A low quoted fee can be entirely fair for one service and irrelevant to another. An annual cost expressed only as a percentage of assets may hide a minimum charge that matters to a smaller relationship.

The calculator below accepts your own quotations. It adds the disclosed annual layers and converts that total into money at a fixed portfolio value. It assumes no returns, withdrawals or compounding. That keeps the exercise narrow: it reconciles charges. It does not predict investment results or establish which manager offers better value.

Reconcile the annual bill

Reconcile your own annual fee quotationsEnter every field. Use zero only when the quote confirms no charge.

This fixed-value arithmetic adds the annual rates, multiplies them by the entered assets and adds fixed costs. It does not model returns, tax, turnover, compounding or missing charges. Inputs stay in your browser.

Separate custody choice from the promise of personal service

An external arrangement can be attractive when the client wants the adviser to remain while custody changes, or wants one investment policy across several custodians. But those freedoms should be tested. Ask how many banks the manager uses in practice, how reporting works across them and whether moving to another bank changes the management fee or available strategy.

A bank mandate can be attractive when the client wants investment management, lending and banking operations within one institution. There may be real administrative advantages. The client should still ask which services depend on keeping a particular mandate and which can continue if management moves elsewhere. Convenience is easier to value when its conditions are visible.

Borrowing deserves particular attention. If assets support a credit facility, a decision about custody may also become a decision about collateral. Ask the lender what can move, what must remain and how much notice it needs. The Lombard-loan guide examines the borrowing side; this comparison concerns the authority and dependency it creates.

However, service also has a less flattering but useful test: absence. Who answers when the main adviser is ill or leaves? Which team can resolve a rejected instruction? Can you obtain records independently? Ask for roles and escalation channels, rather than a promise that somebody will always pick up the telephone.

Make the exit test part of the selection

Finally, imagine that the investment mandate ends next year while every security stays in place. Identify each step needed to reach that outcome. The exercise tests whether the proposed separation of manager and custodian works in practice. It can also reveal a simple bank arrangement that is more flexible than a complicated external one.

Ask about notice periods, unsettled trades, accrued fees and access to historic records. Check whether a successor can obtain the information needed to manage the portfolio and whether the custodian needs new forms. If holdings must move, request a position-level transfer assessment. The ability to stop a mandate and the ability to move every holding are different questions.

A fund, certificate or private-market investment may introduce another party and another timetable. Record who controls redemption, transfer consent and valuation. Do not describe the portfolio as portable until the relevant instruments have been checked. A list of transferable listed shares tells you little about a separate illiquid holding.

Our preference is for an arrangement whose exit can be described before entry. That does not mean frequent switching is desirable. It means the client can evaluate the ongoing relationship without the terms of leaving remaining a mystery. A provider willing to explain that process gives the client a more useful basis for trust.

Choose the arrangement you can verify from abroad

The choice is strongest when the documents agree with the sales conversation. For an external manager, verify the firm, custodian, authority and full charging structure. For a bank mandate, verify the same functions inside the banking relationship. Then compare the practical trade-offs: coordination, independence of records, credit dependencies and the work needed to change providers.

Keep the proposal, signed agreements and a record of unanswered questions in one place. If the investment brief assumes a client classification you do not understand, resolve that too. EGB's explanation of FinSA client classification provides context; an adviser should explain the classification used in your own relationship and its consequences.

Neither model makes a non-resident application automatically acceptable. Nor does choosing a Swiss provider settle the client's home-country obligations. Request confirmation of service scope for your residence, use properly qualified advisers for tax and legal questions, and check the final contract rather than relying on a familiar group name.

If you need help preparing the banking side of the decision, review EGB's services and fees before requesting an assessment. The immediate task is specific: establish who can do what, what each party charges and what happens when you want to change the arrangement. That is a sounder starting point than choosing a label.

Questions readers usually need to resolve

Is an external asset manager mandatory for a complex non-resident file?

Do not treat it as a universal requirement. Ask each prospective provider which channels and evidence it accepts. An introduction does not guarantee acceptance.

Can the manager withdraw my assets?

Read the exact authority accepted by the custodian. A management mandate and a limited power of attorney are not interchangeable; payment, fee and pledge powers need separate checks.

Does independent ownership mean no conflicts?

No. Review product, distribution and connected-party incentives, and ask how they are disclosed and controlled.

Can I keep the bank and replace the manager?

Confirm that with both parties before appointment. Revoking bank authority and terminating the management contract can involve separate steps.

Is the cost calculator a provider ranking?

No. It reconciles the values you enter at a fixed portfolio size. It cannot assess service quality or include charges you have not supplied.

Method, evidence and limitations

This analysis compares contractual roles, not investment performance. Research was checked on 17 November 2026. The authority matrix is an original editorial checklist of questions to confirm, rather than a statement that every mandate grants the same rights. Both charts use dated FINMA observations; the 30% residual is a calculation. Meanwhile, the cost tool uses reader-supplied inputs and retains no data on a server.

There are no invented client outcomes or interviews. The entrepreneur above is illustrative. No bank or manager supplied a personalised quote for this article, and no professional legal review is claimed. Photographs are original AI-generated conceptual scenes, not documentary images of an institution or client. Public documents can change; the signed agreements and the institutions' current written confirmations govern an individual relationship.

This material is general financial information, not personal investment, tax or legal advice. EGB is a banking consultancy, and its involvement does not guarantee account acceptance or investment results. Regulatory status should be checked directly with the relevant official register.

Selected primary references

Portfolio-manager licensing and supervision — FINMA

Managed assets and escalation cases — FINMA, 15 October 2026

Product-risk guidance — FINMA, 3 June 2026

Deposits and custody assets — FINMA

Swiss Banking Ombudsman: advance waivers of retrocessions